HOF Voters Undecided On Proper Number Of Years To Exclude Barry Larkin

Members of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA), the professional organization of journalists who vote annually for such MLB honors as Rookie of the Year, Manager of the Year, and election to the Hall of Fame, have yet to determine the appropriate length of time to exclude former Cincinnati Reds shortstop Barry Larkin from enshrinement into Cooperstown.

“Some guys say 3 years is enough, while others feel 4, 5, or as many as 6 years is more fitting for a player with his offensive statistics,” said Sports Illustrated’s Tom Verducci of the 12-time All Star. “His 2,340 career hits are far below the 3,000 hit benchmark, generally considered the newly approved Best USA Bats for 2018 season for Hall of Fame hitters, but he played during an era when shortstops were more concerned with playing defense, rather than offensive production. So do his 9 Silver Sluggers indicate he was a good hitter, or that other National League shortstops at the time weren’t much for swinging the bat? We can’t decide.”

Larkin’s defense is also making it difficult to conclude if a particular number of years is too short, or too long of a wait.

“He won only 3 Gold Gloves, so I’d say at least a 4 year exclusion. But then again, we need to remember Ozzie Smith was still playing during the early part of Larkin’s career,” Seth Livingstone of USA Today points out. “The ‘Wizard of Oz’ was arguably the greatest fielding shortstop ever, so it’s possible we never appreciated how good Larkin was defensively. Unfortunately, without Gold Gloves, we have no way of determining a player’s worth in the field. Unless we actually watched him play.”

Regardless of their individual review on the 2018 best pitching machine to delay Larkin’s Hall of Fame induction, BBWAA members were in agreement that the 62% of votes Larkin received his second time on the ballot could not have been more perfect.

Posted in mlb

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

RSS Astros RSS Feed

  • Bregman shaved his mustache between at-bats June 24, 2018
    Alex Bregman shaved his mustache between at-bats
    Adrian Garro
  • Yuli's slam caps Astros' 8-run outburst vs. KC June 24, 2018
    First baseman Yuli Gurriel opened a big second inning for the Astros on Saturday with a leadoff double, then provided the big blow with a grand slam at Minute Maid Park.
    Christian Boutwell
  • Reliever Smith throws first bullpen session June 24, 2018
    Astros reliever Joe Smith threw a 30-pitch bullpen session Sunday at Minute Maid Park, his first time throwing off the mound since hitting the disabled list with right elbow soreness earlier this month.
    Christian Boutwell
  • Verlander on hill as Astros open set vs. Toronto June 24, 2018
    Right-hander Justin Verlander (9-2, 1.60 ERA) takes the mound for Monday's 7:10 p.m. CT opener against the Blue Jays at Minute Maid Park. Since losing consecutive starts May 6 and 11, Verlander is 5-0 with a 2.09 ERA, spanning seven starts. Former Astros left-hander J.A. Happ (9-3, 3.56 ERA) will start for Toronto.
  • Beer posts first multihomer game June 24, 2018
    Here's MLB Pipeline's roundup of the top prospect performances in the Minor Leagues on Saturday.
    William Boor
  • Correa's walk-off hit in 12th caps comeback June 24, 2018
    Carlos Correa's walk-off single with the based loaded in the 12th inning won it after the Astros rallied in the ninth on Evan Gattis' sacrifice fly that forced extra frames and helped even the series. Hunter Dozier's homer staked the Royals to an early lead, but the bullpen couldn't hang on after Ian Kennedy's strong […]
    Christian Boutwell
  • Astros prospect Cesar extends hit streak to 40 June 24, 2018
    Astros prospect Randy Cesar extended his Texas League record hit streak to 40 games on Saturday night. He broke Bobby Trevino's nearly five-decade-old record with a hit in his 38th straight game on Thursday.
    David Adler

Recent Posts

GiottoPress by Enrique Chavez

%d bloggers like this: